Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

A comparison of pre-prepared commercial infant feeding meals with home-cooked recipes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle


Sharon Ann Carstairs, Leone C. A. Craig, Debbi Marais, Ourania E. Bora, Kirsty Kiezebrink

School/Research organisations


Objectives. To compare the cost, nutritional and food variety contents of commercial meals and published infant and young child feeding (IYCF) home-cooked recipes, and to compare nutritional contents to age-specific recommendations.
Design. Cross-sectional study.
Setting. Full range of pre-prepared main-meals available within the UK market. Main meal recipes identified from a survey of Amazon’s top 20 bestsellers and IYCF cookbooks available from local libraries.
Samples. 278 commercial IYCF savoury meals from UK market and 408 home-cooked recipes from bestselling IYCF published cookbooks.
Main Outcome Measures. Cost and nutritional content per 100g and food variety per meal for both commercial meals and home-cooked recipes.
Results. Commercial products provided more ‘vegetable’ variety per meal (median=3.0; r=-0.33) than home-cooked recipes (2.0). Recipes provided 26% more energy and 44% more protein and total fat compared to commercial products (r=-0.40, -0.31, -0.40 respectively) whilst costing less (£0.33/100g and £0.68/100g respectively). The majority of commercial products (65%) met energy density recommendations but 50% of home-cooked recipes exceeded the maximum range.
Conclusions. The majority of commercial meals provided an energy dense meal with greater vegetable variety per meal to their home-cooked counterparts. Home-cooked recipes provided a cheaper meal option however the majority exceeded recommendations for energy and fats.


Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1037-1042
JournalArchives of Disease in Childhood
Issue number11
Early online date19 Jul 2016
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2016

    Research areas

  • Infant feeding, Commercial foods, Home-cooked, Food variety, Child feeding

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Can reduced intake associated with downsizing of a high energy dense meal item be offset by increased vegetable variety in 3-5-year-old children?

    Carstairs, S. A., Caton, S. J., Blundell-Birtill, P., Rolls, B. J., Hetherington, M. M. & Cecil, J. E., 3 Dec 2018, In : Nutrients. 10, 12, 15 p., 1879.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. The feasibility and acceptability of two methods of snack portion control in United Kingdom (UK) preschool children: reduction and replacement

    Reale, S., Kearney, C., Hetherington, M., Croden, F., Cecil, J. E., Carstairs, S. A., Rolls, B. & Caton, S., 12 Oct 2018, In : Nutrients. 10, 10, 25 p., 1493.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Downsizing meal items in pre-schoolers using variety

    Cecil, J. E., Carstairs, S., Caton, S., Blundell-Birtill, P., Rolls, B. & Hetherington, M. M., 1 Apr 2018, In : Appetite. 123, p. 460

    Research output: Contribution to journalAbstract

  4. How important are the influencing factors to the decision on whether to provide seafood in infant and young child feeding?

    Carstairs, S. A., Marais, D., Craig, L. C. A. & Kiezebrink, K., 1 Oct 2017, In : Appetite. 117, p. 224-233 10 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Related by journal

  1. G246 Management of acute malnutrition in infants aged <6 months (mami) in Malawi: prevalence and risk factors in an observational study

    Karunaratne, R., Lilijveld, N., Newberry, L., Kumwenda, E., Lang, H. J., Cartmell, E., McGrath, M., O'Hare, B. A-M., Nyirenda, M., Kennedy, N. & Kerac, M., Jun 2015, In : Archives of Disease in Childhood.

    Research output: Contribution to journalAbstract

  2. Upstream barriers to child mortality reduction: the case of Sub Saharan Africa

    O'Hare, B. A-M., Makuta, I., Chiwaula, L. & Bar-Zeev, N., 1 Jun 2014, In : Archives of Disease in Childhood. 99, Suppl. 1, A123 .

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. The value of including Global Health in the training of health professionals

    Molyneux, E. & O'Hare, B. A-M., 1 Nov 2013, In : Archives of Disease in Childhood. 98, p. 840-842

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. Rash associated with Heaf test

    Menon, L., Davies, I., O'Hare, B. & Hutton, K., Aug 2006, In : Archives of Disease in Childhood. 91, 8, p. 670-670 1 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalEditorial

ID: 245113138