Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Classical trinitarianism and eternal functional subordination: some historical and dogmatic reflections

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle


School/Research organisations


Within Anglophone evangelical theology and church life there has been much debate in recent months over the idea of ‘eternal functional subordination’ (EFS) or ‘eternal relationships of authority and submission’ (ERAS). To ask whether EFS/ERAS are adequately trinitarian we must first define ‘trinitarian’. Following Barnes, I argue that the only possible definition is historical. To be ‘trinitarian’ is to hold to the doctrine developed in the fourth-century debates. By insisting on a strong distinction between the divine life in se and the economic acts of God, I rule out any appeal to, for instance, the pactum salutis in an attempt to defend EFS/ERAS. A consideration of the Father-Son relationship suggests two possible defences of such positions, one relying on finding an eternal analogue to the economic ordering of the divine acts, and the other pressing ‘Father-Son’ language to suggest that the relationship of eternal generation might entail something like EFS/ERAS. An examination of what must be said concerning the simple divine essence, however, excludes both these possibilities. I argue, therefore, that EFS, ERAS, or any similar doctrines are incompatible with classical trinitarianism.


Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)90-104
JournalScottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology
Issue number1
StatePublished - 11 Jul 2017

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Penal Substitutionary Atonement

    Holmes, S. R. Aug 2017 T&T Clark Companion on the Atonement. T&T Clark

    Research output: ResearchChapter

  2. The courage to be Baptist: a statement on Baptist ecclesiology and human sexuality

    Allison-Glenny, B., Goodliff, A., Gouldbourne, R., Holmes, S., Kerrigan, D., Marshall, G. & Woodman, S. 3 Jan 2017 In : Baptist Quarterly. 48, 1, p. 2-10 9 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  3. Radicalising the Communicatio: Jenson’s theology in confessional Lutheran perspective

    Holmes, S. R. 2017 Constrictive Responses to Robert Jenson. Augsburg Fortress Publishers

    Research output: ResearchChapter

  4. On not handling snakes: Late modern cultural assumptions about sexuality

    Holmes, S. R. 2017 (Accepted/In press) Marriage, Family, and Relationships. Noble, T., Whittle, S. & Johnston, P. (eds.). IVP

    Research output: ResearchChapter

  5. Traditional View: Theological Defence

    Holmes, S. R. Nov 2016 (Accepted/In press) Counterpoints: Two Views on Human Sexuality. Zondervan

    Research output: ResearchChapter

Related by journal

  1. One Eternal God

    Holmes, S. R. 2014 In : Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology. 32, 1, p. 28-39

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  2. Evangelical Theology: Basis of Unity or Cause of Division?

    Holmes, S. R. 2012 In : Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology. 30, 1, p. 51-65 15 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  3. Bavinck's Use of Augustine as an Antidote to Ritschl

    Elliott, M. W. 2011 In : Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology. 29, 1, p. 24-40 17 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  4. Bavinck’s use of Augustine as an antidote to Ritschl.’

    Elliott, M. W. 2011 In : Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology. 29 (2011), p. 24-40.

    Research output: ResearchBook/Film/Article review

Related by journal

  1. Scottish Bulletin of Evangelical Theology (Journal)

    Nathan MacDonald (Editor)

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial workEditor of research journal

ID: 250099013