Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Do reverberation mapping analyses provide an accurate picture of the broad line region?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

DOI

Open Access permissions

Open

Author(s)

S. W. Mangham, C. Knigge, P. Williams, Keith Horne, A. Pancoast, J. H. Matthews, K. S. Long, S. A. Sim, N. Higginbottom

School/Research organisations

Abstract

Reverberation mapping (RM) is a powerful approach for determining the nature of the broad-line region (BLR) in active galactic nuclei. However, inferring physical BLR properties from an observed spectroscopic time series is a difficult inverse problem. Here, we present a blind test of two widely used RM methods: MEMEcho (developed by Horne) and CARAMEL (developed by Pancoast and collaborators). The test data are simulated spectroscopic time series that track the Hα emission line response to an empirical continuum light curve. The underlying BLR model is a rotating, biconical accretion disc wind, and the synthetic spectra are generated via self-consistent ionization and radiative transfer simulations. We generate two mock data sets, representing Seyfert galaxies and QSOs. The Seyfert model produces a largely negative response, which neither method can recover. However, both fail “gracefully”, neither generating spurious results. For the QSO model both CARAMEL and expert interpretation of MEMEchoś output both capture the broadly annular, rotation-dominated nature of the line-forming region, though MEMEcho analysis overestimates its size by 50%, but CARAMEL is unable to distinguish between additional inflow and outflow components. Despite fitting individual spectra well, the CARAMEL velocity-delay maps and RMS line profiles are strongly inconsistent with the input data. Finally, since the Hα line-forming region is rotation dominated, neither method recovers the disc wind nature of the underlying BLR model. Thus considerable care is required when interpreting the results of RM analyses in terms of physical models.
Close

Details

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2780-2799
JournalMonthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Volume488
Issue number2
Early online date21 Jun 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2019

    Research areas

  • Accretion discs, Radiative transfer, Quasars: general

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. ROME/REA: a gravitational microlensing search for exoplanets beyond the snow line on a global network of robotic telescopes

    Tsapras, Y., Street, R. A., Hundertmark, M., Bachelet, E., Dominik, M., Bozza, V., Cassan, A., Wambsganss, J., Horne, K. D., Mao, S., Zang, W., Bramich, D. M. & Saha, A., 11 Oct 2019, In : Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific. 131, 1006, p. 1-12 12 p., 1244401.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Full orbital solution for the binary system in the Northern Galactic Disk microlensing event Gaia16aye

    Wyrzykowski, Ł., Mróz, P., Rybicki, K. A., Gromadzki, M., Kołaczkowski, Z., Zieliński, M., Zieliński, P., Britavskiy, N., Gomboc, A., Sokolovsky, K., Hodgkin, S. T., Abe, L., Aldi, G. F., AlMannaei, A., Altavilla, G., Qasim, A. A., Anupama, G. C., Awiphan, S., Bachelet, E., Bakis, V. & 152 others, Baker, S., Bartlett, S., Bendjoya, P., Benson, K., Bikmaev, I. F., Birenbaum, G., Blagorodnova, N., Blanco-Cuaresma, S., Boeva, S., Bonanos, A. Z., Bozza, V., Bramich, D. M., Bruni, I., Burenin, R. A., Burgaz, U., Butterley, T., Caines, H. E., Caton, D. B., Calchi Novati, S., Carrasco, J. M., Cassan, A., Čepas, V., Cropper, M., Chruślińska, M., Clementini, G., Clerici, A., Conti, D., Conti, M., Cross, S., Cusano, F., Damljanovic, G., Dapergolas, A., D'Ago, G., de Bruijne, J. H. J., Dennefeld, M., Dhillon, V. S., Dominik, M., Dziedzic, J., Erece, O., Eselevich, M. V., Esenoglu, H., Eyer, L., Figuera Jaimes, R., Fossey, S. J., Galeev, A. I., Grebenev, S. A., Gupta, A. C., Gutaev, A. G., Hallakoun, N., Hamanowicz, A., Han, C., Handzlik, B., Haislip, J. B., Hardy, L. K., Harrison, D. L., Hoette, V. L., Horne, K., Hudec, R., Hundertmark, M., Ihanec, N., Irtuganov, E. N., Itoh, R., Iwanek, P., Jovanovic, M. D., Janulis, R., Jelinek, M., Jensen, E., Kaczmarek, Z., Katz, D., Khamitov, I. M., Kilic, Y., Klencki, J., Kolb, U., Kouprianov, V. V., Kruszyńska, K., Kurowski, S., Latev, G., Lee, C-H., Leonini, S., Leto, G., Lewis, F., Li, Z., Liakos, A., Littlefair, S. P., Lu, J., Manser, C. J., Mao, S., Maoz, D., Maskoliunas, M., Maund, J. R., Melnikov, S. S., Ment, K., Mikołajczyk, P., Morrell, M., Mowlavi, N., Moździerski, D., Nazarov, S., Netzel, H., Nesci, R., Ngeow, C-C., Norton, A. J., Ofek, E. O., Pakstiene, E., Palaversa, L., Pandey, A., Paraskeva, E., Pawlak, M., Penny, M. T., Penprase, B. E., Piascik, A., Prieto, J. L., Qvam, J. K. T., Ranc, C., Rebassa-Mansergas, A., Reichart, D. E., Reig, P., Rhodes, L., Rivet, J-P., Rixon, G., Roberts, D., Rosi, P., Russell, D. M., Zanmar Sanchez, R., Scarpetta, G., Seabroke, G., Shappee, B. J., Schmidt, R., Shvartzvald, Y., Sitek, M., Skowron, J., Śniegowska, M., Snodgrass, C., Soares, P. S., Spetsieri, Z. T., Stankeviciute, A., Steele, I. A., Street, R. A., Strobl, J., Tinjaca Ramirez, L. M., Tomasella, L., Tsapras, Y., Villanueva, S. . J., Vince, O., Wambsganss, J., Wiersema, K., Wilson, R. W., Yoldas, A., Zhuchkov, R. Y., Zhukov, D. G., Zdanavicius, J., Zoła, S. & Zubareva, A., 11 Oct 2019, (Accepted/In press) In : Astronomy & Astrophysics.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. The first spectroscopic dust reverberation programme on active galactic nuclei: the torus in NGC 5548

    Landt, H., Ward, M. J., Kynoch, D., Packham, C., Ferland, G. J., Lawrence, A., Pott, J. -U., Esser, J., Horne, K., Starkey, D. A., Malhotra, D., Fausnaugh, M. M., Peterson, B. M., Wilman, R. J., Riffel, R. A., Storchi-Bergmann, T., Barth, A. J., Villforth, C. & Winkler, H., Oct 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 489, 2, p. 1572–1589

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. Two new HATNet hot Jupiters around A stars, and the first glimpse at the occurrence rate of hot Jupiters from TESS*

    Zhou, G., Huang, C. X., Bakos, G. Á., Hartman, J. D., Latham, D. W., Quinn, S. N., Collins, K. A., Winn, J. N., Wong, I., Kovács, G., Csubry, Z., Bhatti, W., Penev, K., Bieryla, A., Esquerdo, G. A., Berlind, P., Calkins, M. L., de Val-Borro, M., Noyes, R. W., Lázár, J. & 51 others, Papp, I., Sári, P., Kovács, T., Buchhave, L. A., Szklenar, T., Béky, B., Johnson, M. C., Cochran, W. D., Kniazev, A. Y., Stassun, K. G., Fulton, B. J., Shporer, A., Espinoza, N., Bayliss, D., Everett, M., Howell, S. B., Hellier, C., Anderson, D. R., Cameron, A. C., West, R. G., Brown, D. J. A., Schanche, N., Barkaoui, K., Pozuelos, F., Gillon, M., Jehin, E., Benkhaldoun, Z., Daassou, A., Ricker, G., Vanderspek, R., Seager, S., Jenkins, J. M., Lissauer, J. J., Armstrong, J. D., Collins, K. I., Gan, T., Hart, R., Horne, K., Kielkopf, J. F., Nielsen, L. D., Nishiumi, T., Narita, N., Palle, E., Relles, H. M., Sefako, R., Tan, T. G., Davies, M., Goeke, R. F., Guerrero, N., Haworth, K. & Villanueva, S., Oct 2019, In : Astronomical Journal. 158, 4, p. 1-24 24 p., 141.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  5. OGLE-2015-BLG-1649Lb: a gas giant planet around a low-mass dwarf

    Nagakane, M., Lee, C-H., Koshimoto, N., Suzuki, D., Udalski, A., Beaulieu, J-P., Sumi, T., Bennett, D., Bond, I. A., Rattenbury, N. J., Bachelet, E., Dominik, M., Abe, F., Barry, R., Bhattacharya, A., Donachie, M., Fujii, H., Fukui, A., Hirao, Y., Itow, Y. & 49 others, Kamei, Y., Kondo, I., Li, M. C. A., Matsubara, Y., Matsuo, T., Miyazaki, S., Muraki, Y., Ranc, C., Shibai, H., Suematsu, H., Sullivan, D., Tristram, P., Yamakawa, T., Yonehara, A., Mróz, P., Poleski, R., Skowron, J., Szymański, M., Soszyński, I., Pietrukowicz, P., Kozłowski, S., Ulaczyk, K., Bramich, D., Cassan, A., Jaimes, R., Horne, K., Hundertmark, M., Mao, S., Menzies, J., Schmidt, R., Snodgrass, C., Steele, I., Street, R., Tsapras, Y., Wambsganss, J., Jørgensen, U., Bozza, V., Longã, P., Peixinho, N., Skottfelt, J., Southworth, J., Andersen, M. I., Burgdorf, M., D'Ago, G., Evans, D., Hinse, T., Korhonen, H., Rabus, M. & Rahvar, S., 25 Sep 2019, (Accepted/In press) In : Astronomical Journal.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Related by journal

  1. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Journal)

    Ineke De Moortel (Member of editorial board)
    1 Jan 2019 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  2. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Journal)

    Carolin Villforth (Reviewer)
    2011 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  3. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Journal)

    Christiane Helling (Editor)
    2007 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  4. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Journal)

    Andrew Collier Cameron (Editor)
    2005 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  5. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (Journal)

    Duncan Hendry Mackay (Editor)
    2003 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

Related by journal

  1. Chandra reveals a possible ultrafast outflow in the super-Eddington Be/X-ray binary Swift J0243.6+6124

    van den Eijnden, J., Degenaar, N., Schulz, N. S., Nowak, M. A., Wijnands, R., Russell, T. D., Hernández Santisteban, J. V., Bahramian, A., Maccarone, T. J., Kennea, J. A. & Heinke, C. O., Aug 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 487, 3, p. 4355-4371

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. A new formulation of the external field effect in MOND and numerical simulations of ultra-diffuse dwarf galaxies - application to NGC 1052-DF2 and NGC 1052-DF4

    Haghi, H., Kroupa, P., Banik, I., Wu, X., Zonoozi, A. H., Javanmardi, B., Ghari, A., Mueller, O., Dabringhausen, J. & Zhao, H., Aug 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 487, 2, p. 2441-2454 14 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. A re-establishing jet during an X-ray re-brightening of the Be/X-ray binary Swift J0243.6+6124

    van den Eijnden, J., Degenaar, N., Russell, T. D., Hernández Santisteban, J. V., Wijnands, R., Miller-Jones, J. C. A., Rouco Escorial, A. & Sivakoff, G. R., Mar 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 483, 4, p. 4628-4638

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. An analysis of binary microlensing event OGLE-2015-BLG-0060

    Tsapras, Y., Cassan, A., Ranc, C., Bachelet, E., Street, R., Udalski, A., Hundertmark, M., Bozza, V., Beaulieu, J. P., Marquette, J. B., Euteneuer, E., Bramich, D. M., Dominik, M., Figuera Jaimes, R., Horne, K., Mao, S., Menzies, J., Schmidt, R., Snodgrass, C., Steele, I. A. & 61 others, Wambsganss, J., Mróz, P., Szymański, M. K., Soszyński, I., Skowron, J., Pietrukowicz, P., Kozłowski, S., Poleski, R., Ulaczyk, K., Pawlak, M., Jørgensen, U. G., Skottfelt, J., Popovas, A., Ciceri, S., Korhonen, H., Kuffmeier, M., Evans, D. F., Peixinho, N., Hinse, T. C., Burgdorf, M. J., Southworth, J., Tronsgaard, R., Kerins, E., Andersen, M. I., Rahvar, S., Wang, Y., Wertz, O., Rabus, M., Calchi Novati, S., D'Ago, G., Scarpetta, G., Mancini, L., Abe, F., Asakura, Y., Bennett, D. P., Bhattacharya, A., Donachie, M., Evans, P., Fukui, A., Hirao, Y., Itow, Y., Kawasaki, K., Koshimoto, N., Li, M. C. A., Ling, C. H., Masuda, K., Matsubara, Y., Muraki, Y., Miyazaki, S., Nagakane, M., Ohnishi, K., Rattenbury, N., Saito, T., Sharan, A., Shibai, H., Sullivan, D. J., Sumi, T., Suzuki, D., Tristram, P. J., Yamada, T. & Yonehara, A., Aug 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. 487, 4, p. 4603–4614

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  5. Anomalous behaviour of the UV-optical continuum bands in NGC 5548

    Goad, M. R., Knigge, C., Korista, K. T., Cackett, E., Horne, K., Starkey, D. A., Peterson, B. M., De Rosa, G., Kriss, G. A., Edelson, R. & Fausnaugh, M., 30 Apr 2019, In : Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

ID: 259383221

Top