Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Hermione's Sophism: Ordinariness and Theatricality in The Winter's Tale

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle


Open Access permissions



School/Research organisations


This essay probes a Wittgensteinian understanding of human conversation within a close reading of Shakespeare’s The Winter’s Tale. Relating Stanley Cavell’s well-known interpretation of Shakespeare’s plays as engagements with skepticism to Rush Rhees’s work on the possibility of discourse, I argue that Cavellian acknowledgement and Rheesian ‘unity’ (of discourse with life) may fruitfully be read together as two complimentary conditions for genuine conversation, and therefore genuine human understanding. Reiterating Cavell’s reading of Leontes as repudiating the first of these criteria, I then argue that Hermione, far from being merely a passive victim of his madness, is an active contributor to the disintegration of their relationship by repudiating the second criterion in favor of a ‘sophistic’ use of language as mere play. With this interpretive framework in place, I analyze how The Winter’s Tale not merely illuminates but also complicates Cavell’s and Rhees’s criteria through a constant engagement with its own theatricality. Rather than merely exposing the threat of ‘theatricalization’ or sophism (as Cavell or Rhees might wish), the play also insists that all relationships have theatrical aspects that must be worked through rather than repudiated.


Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)A83-A105
JournalPhilosophy and Literature
Issue number1A
StatePublished - Sep 2015

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Creation and Eschatology

    Wolfe, J. 2019 (In preparation) Oxford Handbook of Creation. Oliver, S. (ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewChapter (peer-reviewed)

  2. Weimar Eschatology

    Wolfe, J. Oct 2018 (In preparation) In : Modern Theology.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  3. Revelation in the Thought of Martin Heidegger

    Wolfe, J. 2018 (In preparation) Oxford Handbook of Revelation. Mezei, B., Murphy, F. A. & Oakes, K. (eds.). Oxford: Oxford University Press

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewChapter (peer-reviewed)

  4. European philosophy and original sin in Stephen Mulhall

    Wolfe, J. Jul 2017 In : New Blackfriars. 98, 1076, p. 387–398

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  5. Religion in Heidegger's Black Notebooks: Overview and Analysis

    Wolfe, J. 2017 (Accepted/In press) Black Thoughts: Heidegger and the Future of Theology. Svenungsson, J. & Björk, M. (eds.). London: Palgrave

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewChapter (peer-reviewed)

Related by journal

  1. Irony as a way of life: Svevo, Kierkegaard and psychoanalysis

    Bond, E. F. Oct 2016 In : Philosophy and Literature. 40, 2, p. 431-445

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  2. Was Effi Briest A Victim of Kantian Morality?

    BARON, M. Apr 1988 In : Philosophy and Literature. 12, 1, p. 95-113 19 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewComment/debate

ID: 105053733