Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Managing the growth of peer review at the Royal Society journals, 1865-1965

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Author(s)

Aileen Fyfe, Flaminio Squazzoni, Didier Torny, Pierpaolo Dondio

School/Research organisations

Abstract

This article examines the evolution of peer review and the modern editorial processes of scholarly journals by analyzing a novel dataset derived from the Royal Society’s archives and covering 1865 to 1965, i.e., the historical period in which refereeing (not yet known as peer review) became firmly established. Our analysis reveals how the Royal Society’s editorial processes coped with both an increasing reliance on refereeing and a growth in submissions, while maintaining collective responsibility and minimizing research waste. By engaging more of its fellows in editorial activity, the society was able to establish an equilibrium of number of submissions per reviewer that was relatively stable over time. Nevertheless, our analysis shows that the distribution of editorial work was significantly uneven. Our findings reveal interesting parallels with current concerns about the scale and distribution of peer-review work and suggest the strategic importance of the management of the editorial process to achieve a creative mix of community commitment and professional responsibility that is essential in contemporary journals.
Close

Details

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages25
JournalScience, Technology and Human Values
VolumeOnline First
Early online date15 Jul 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 15 Jul 2019

    Research areas

  • Peer review, Scholarly journals, Editorial work, Royal Society, Responsibility

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Open Scholarship and the need for collective action

    Neylon, C., Belso, R., Bijsterbosch, M., Cordewener, B., Foncel, J., Friesike, S., Fyfe, A., Jacobs, N., Katerbow, M., Laakso, M. & Sesink, L., 11 Oct 2019, Bristol : Knowledge Exchange. 97 p.

    Research output: Book/ReportBook

  2. Scientific Publications

    Fyfe, A., 27 Sep 2019, Companion to the History of the Book (2nd edition). Rose, J. & Eliot, S. (eds.). Wiley-Blackwell

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

  3. What the history of copyright in academic publishing tells us about Open Research

    Fyfe, A., 3 Jun 2019

    Research output: Non-textual formWeb publication/site

  4. It's not all about the money: To help learned societies adjust to Plan S, treat them as more than just publishers

    Fyfe, A., 1 May 2019, Research Fortnight, p. 15 1 p.

    Research output: Contribution to specialist publicationArticle

  5. Opening up access to research: a film review of Paywall: the Business of Scholarship, directed and produced by Jason Schmitt, 2018

    Fyfe, A., 18 Apr 2019, Endeavour, In press.

    Research output: Contribution to specialist publicationBook/Film/Article review

ID: 259114733

Top