Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Monsters and the theoretical role of context

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle



Kaplan (1989) famously claimed that monsters—operators that shift the context—do not exist in English and “could not be added to it”. Several re- cent theorists have pointed out a range of data that seem to refute Kaplan’s claim, but others (most explicitly Stalnaker 2014) have offered a principled argument that monsters are impossible. This paper interprets and resolves the dispute. Contra appearances, this is no dry, technical matter: it cuts to the heart of a deep disagreement about the fundamental structure of a semantic theory. We argue that: (i) the interesting notion of a monster is not an operator that shifts some formal parameter, but rather an operator that shifts parameters that play a certain theoretical role; (ii) one cannot determine whether a given semantic theory allows monsters simply by look- ing at the formal semantics; (iii) theories which forbid shifting the formal “context” parameter are perfectly compatible with the existence of monsters (in the interesting sense). We explain and defend these claims by contrasting two kinds of semantic theory—Kaplan’s (1989) and Lewis’s (1980).


Original languageEnglish
JournalPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research
VolumeEarly View
Early online date6 Oct 2017
StateE-pub ahead of print - 6 Oct 2017

    Research areas

  • Semantics, Content, Monsters, Context sensitivity, David Kaplan, David Lewis, Context shifting

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Review of Semantics, Metasemantics, Aboutness

    Ball, D. 29 Nov 2017 In : Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews.

    Research output: ResearchBook/Film/Article review

  2. What are we doing when we theorise about context sensitivity?

    Ball, D. N. 22 Mar 2017 The Routledge Handbook of Epistemic Contextualism. Ichikawa, J. J. (ed.). Routledge, (Routledge Handbooks in Philosophy)

    Research output: ResearchChapter

  3. Knowing without knowing: implicit cognition and the minds of infants and animals

    Gomez, J-C., Kersken, V. A., Ball, D. N. & Seed, A. M. 2017 In : Estudios de Psicología. 38, 1, p. 37-62 26 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  4. Review of The Myth of the Intuitive, by Max Deutsch

    Ball, D. N. 2017 In : Australasian Journal of Philosophy. 95, 2, p. 414-415

    Research output: ResearchBook/Film/Article review

  5. No help on the hard problem

    Ball, D. N. 17 Nov 2016 In : Animal Sentience. 2016, 11, p. 1-3 3 p.

    Research output: ResearchComment/debate

Related by journal

  1. Looks and perceptual justification

    McGrath, M. 13 Jan 2018 In : Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 96, 1, p. 110-133

    Research output: ResearchArticle

  2. Contextualism about evidential support

    Brown, J. A. Mar 2016 In : Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 92, 2, p. 329-354 26 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  3. Games, beliefs and credences

    Weatherson, B. J. Mar 2016 In : Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 92, 2, p. 209-236 28 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

ID: 249597186