Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Spot sputum samples are at least as good as early morning samples for identifying Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Author(s)

Michael E. Murphy, Patrick P. J. Phillips, Carl M. Mendel, Emily Bongard, Anna L. C. Bateson, Robert Hunt, Saraswathi Murthy, Kasha P. Singh, Michael Brown, Angela M. Crook, Andrew J. Nunn, Sarah K. Meredith, Marc Lipman, Timothy D. McHugh, Stephen H. Gillespie, REMoxTB Consortium

School/Research organisations

Abstract

Background:  The use of early morning sputum samples (EMS) to diagnose tuberculosis (TB) can result in treatment delay given the need for the patient to return to the clinic with the EMS, increasing the chance of patients being lost during their diagnostic workup. However, there is little evidence to support the superiority of EMS over spot sputum samples. In this new analysis of the REMoxTB study, we compare the diagnostic accuracy of EMS with spot samples for identifying Mycobacterium tuberculosis pre- and post-treatment.
Methods:  Patients who were smear positive at screening were enrolled into the study. Paired sputum samples (one EMS and one spot) were collected at each trial visit pre- and post-treatment. Microscopy and culture on solid LJ and liquid MGIT media were performed on all samples; those missing corresponding paired results were excluded from the analyses.
Results:  Data from 1115 pre- and 2995 post-treatment paired samples from 1931 patients enrolled in the REMoxTB study were analysed. Patients were recruited from South Africa (47%), East Africa (21%), India (20%), Asia (11%), and North America (1%); 70% were male, median age 31 years (IQR 24–41), 139 (7%) co-infected with HIV with a median CD4 cell count of 399 cells/μL (IQR 318–535). Pre-treatment spot samples had a higher yield of positive Ziehl–Neelsen smears (98% vs. 97%, P = 0.02) and LJ cultures (87% vs. 82%, P = 0.006) than EMS, but there was no difference for positivity by MGIT (93% vs. 95%, P = 0.18). Contaminated and false-positive MGIT were found more often with EMS rather than spot samples. Surprisingly, pre-treatment EMS had a higher smear grading and shorter time-to-positivity, by 1 day, than spot samples in MGIT culture (4.5 vs. 5.5 days, P < 0.001). There were no differences in time to positivity in pre-treatment LJ culture, or in post-treatment MGIT or LJ cultures. Comparing EMS and spot samples in those with unfavourable outcomes, there were no differences in smear or culture results, and positive results were not detected earlier in Kaplan–Meier analyses in either EMS or spot samples.
Conclusions:  Our data do not support the hypothesis that EMS samples are superior to spot sputum samples in a clinical trial of patients with smear positive pulmonary TB. Observed small differences in mycobacterial burden are of uncertain significance and EMS samples do not detect post-treatment positives any sooner than spot samples.
Close

Details

Original languageEnglish
Article number192
Number of pages10
JournalBMC Medicine
Volume15
DOIs
StatePublished - 27 Oct 2017

    Research areas

  • Tuberculosis, Smear microscopy, Early morning sputum, Spot sputum, Diagnostics

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Gender differences in tuberculosis treatment outcomes: a post hoc analysis of the REMoxTB study

    Murphy, M. E., Wills, G. H., Murthy, S., Louw, C., Bateson, A. L. C., Hunt, R. D., McHugh, T. D., Nunn, A. J., Meredith, S. K., Mendel, C. M., Spigelman, M., Crook, A. M., Gillespie, S. H. & REMoxTB Consortium 17 Oct 2018 In : BMC Medicine. 16, 11 p., 189

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Phenotypic changes on Mycobacterium tuberculosis-specific CD4 T cells as surrogate markers for tuberculosis treatment efficacy

    Ahmed, M. I. M. , Ntinginya, N. E. , Kibiki, G. , Mtafya, B. A. , Semvua, H. , Mpagama, S. , Mtabho, C. , Saathoff, E. , Held, K. , Loose, R. , Kroidl, I. , Chachage, M. , Both, U. V. , Haule, A. , Mekota, A-M. , Boeree, M. J. , Gillespie, S. H. , Hoelscher, M. , Heinrich, N. , Geldmacher, C. & 1 others Pan African Consortium for the Evaluation of Antituberculosis Antibiotics (PanACEA) 28 Sep 2018 In : Frontiers in Immunology. 9, 13 p., 2247

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Centrifugation and decontamination procedures selectively impair recovery of important populations in Mycobacterium smegmatis

    Kennedy, J. A., Baron, V. O., Hammond, R. J. H., Sloan, D. J. & Gillespie, S. H. 1 Aug 2018 In : Tuberculosis.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. Toxicity associated with tuberculosis chemotherapy in the REMoxTB study

    Tweed, C. D., Crook, A. M., Amukoye, E. I., Dawson, R., Diacon, A. H., Hanekom, M., McHugh, T. D., Mendel, C. M., Meredith, S. K., Murphy, M. E., Murthy, S. E., Nunn, A. J., Phillips, P. P. J., Singh, K. P., Spigelman, M., Wills, G. H. & Gillespie, S. H. 11 Jul 2018 In : BMC Infectious Diseases. 18, 11 p., 317

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Related by journal

  1. Gender differences in tuberculosis treatment outcomes: a post hoc analysis of the REMoxTB study

    Murphy, M. E., Wills, G. H., Murthy, S., Louw, C., Bateson, A. L. C., Hunt, R. D., McHugh, T. D., Nunn, A. J., Meredith, S. K., Mendel, C. M., Spigelman, M., Crook, A. M., Gillespie, S. H. & REMoxTB Consortium 17 Oct 2018 In : BMC Medicine. 16, 11 p., 189

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Liver toxicity associated with tuberculosis chemotherapy in the REMoxTB study

    Tweed, C. D., Wills, G. H., Crook, A. M., Dawson, R., Diacon, A. H., Louw, C. E., McHugh, T. D., Mendel, C., Meredith, S., Mohapi, L., Murphy, M. E., Murray, S., Murthy, S., Nunn, A. J., Phillips, P. P. J., Singh, K., Spigelman, M. & Gillespie, S. H. 28 Mar 2018 In : BMC Medicine. 16, 10 p., 46

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Pretreatment chest x-ray severity and its relation to bacterial burden in smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis

    Murthy, S. E., Chatterjee, F., Crook, A., Dawson, R., Mendel, C., Murphy, M. E., Murray, S. R., Nunn, A. J., Phillips, P. P. J., Singh, K. P., McHugh, T. D., Gillespie, S. H. & REMoxTB Consortium 21 May 2018 In : BMC Medicine. 16, 11 p., 73

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. A comparison of liquid and solid culture for determining relapse and durable cure in phase III TB trials for new regimens

    Phillips, P. P. J., Mendel, C. M., Nunn, A. J., McHugh, T. D., Crook, A. M., Hunt, R., Bateson, A. & Gillespie, S. H. 24 Nov 2017 In : BMC Medicine. 15, 9 p., 207

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  5. Overcoming intratumoural heterogeneity for reproducible molecular risk stratification: a case study in advanced kidney cancer

    Lubbock, A. L. R., Stewart, G. D., O'Mahoney, F. C., Laird, A., Mullen, P., O'Donnell, M., Powles, T., Harrison, D. J. & Overton, I. M. 26 Jun 2017 In : BMC Medicine. 15, 12 p., 118

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

ID: 251439321