Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

Suffering and covenantal hope in Galatians: a critique of the 'apocalyptic reading' and its proponents

Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

DOI

Author(s)

J.A. Dunne

School/Research organisations

Abstract

This article addresses the so-called 'apocalyptic reading of Paul', taking the representative work of J. Louis Martyn and Martinus C. de Boer as its primary focus. The chief contention is that the 'apocalyptic reading' does not resemble the historical phenomenon of Jewish apocalyptic literature, although the scope of this article has been intentionally limited to Galatians. The present study is composed of two halves. The first half offers a critique of what it means for Paul to be an apocalyptic thinker according to Martyn and de Boer. Their emphasis is on discontinuity, duality and dichotomy, which coheres neither with first-century apocalyptic literature and its antecedents, nor with the letter to the Galatians. Their nuanced notion of apocalyptic has led to an unnecessary bifurcation between apocalyptic and covenant (not to mention Heilsgeschichte) in the interpretation of Paul. However, this article suggests that the dichotomy has been misplaced, both in relation to the discontinuity that Paul does articulate (i.e. with the law), and the dichotomy reflected in apocalyptic literature, namely, the division between the present evil age and the glorious age to come. Thus, it is argued that Martyn and de Boer's focus on discontinuity hardly constitutes apocalyptic in a first-century historical sense. Rather, their specific emphasis owes its articulation to the theology of Karl Barth. After arguing that the 'apocalyptic reading' lacks historical precision (and possibly theological forthrightness), the second half of the study argues that some neglected features of Galatians, such as suffering and persecution, cohere with the apocalyptic character of the letter, and are common features of apocalyptic broadly. In fact, the division between apocalyptic and covenant in scholarship on Galatians is bridged by the themes of conflict and crisis. This is because apocalyptic hope often arises in the absence of the realisation of covenantal promises and expectations; a covenantal disconnect is created and aggravated by crises and hardships of various sorts, hence the need for apocalyptic hope. Suffering therefore ties together the strands of apocalyptic and covenant in Galatians. If Martyn and de Boer's 'apocalyptic reading' was truly apocalyptic in a first-century historical sense, it would have integrated the imagery of suffering and persecution found in the letter.
Close

Details

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-15
Number of pages15
JournalScottish Journal of Theology
Volume68
Issue number1
Early online date9 Jan 2015
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 2015

    Research areas

  • Apocalyptic, Covenant, Martinus C. de Boer, Galatians, J. Louis Martyn, Paul, Persecution, Suffering

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by journal

  1. Review of Sartre and Theology

    Wolfe, J. 20 Apr 2018 (Accepted/In press) In : Scottish Journal of Theology. In press

    Research output: ResearchBook/Film/Article review

  2. Putting hell first: cruelty, historicism, and the missing moral theory of damnation

    Perry, J. Feb 2016 In : Scottish Journal of Theology. 69, 1, p. 1-19 20 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewArticle

  3. Galatians and the imperial cult: a critical analysis of the first-century social context of Paul's letter

    Dunne, J. A. May 2014 In : Scottish Journal of Theology. 67, 2, p. 245-246 2 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewBook/Film/Article review

  4. God and the art of happiness

    Perry, J. Feb 2014 In : Scottish Journal of Theology. 67, 1, p. 112-113 2 p.

    Research output: Research - peer-reviewBook/Film/Article review

ID: 164213192