Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

The effect of experimental design on the measurement of mate choice: a meta-analysis

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articlepeer-review

DOI

Abstract

Quantifying the shape and strength of mating preferences is a vital component of the study of sexual selection and reproductive isolation, but the influence of experimental design on these estimates is unclear. Mating preferences may be tested using either no-choice or choice designs, and these tests may result in different estimates of preference strength. However, previous studies testing for this difference have given mixed results. To quantify the difference in the strength of mating preferences obtained using the 2 designs, we performed a meta-analysis of 38 studies on 40 species in which both experimental designs were used to test for preferences in a single species/trait/sex combination. We found that mating preferences were significantly stronger when tested using a choice design compared with a no-choice design. We suggest that this difference is due to the increased cost of rejecting partners in no-choice tests; if individuals perceive they are unlikely to remate in a no-choice situation they will be more likely to mate randomly. Importantly the use of choice tests in species in which mates are primarily encountered sequentially in the wild may lead to mating preferences being significantly overestimated. Furthermore, this pattern was seen for female mate choice but not for male mate choice, and for intraspecific choice but not for interspecies or interpopulation mate discrimination. Our study thus highlights the fact that the strength of mating preferences, and thus sexual selection, can vary significantly between experimental designs and across different social and ecological contexts.

Close

Details

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)311-319
Number of pages9
JournalBehavioral Ecology
Volume26
Issue number2
Early online date29 Aug 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2015

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. Context-dependent use of visual cues in the shell selection behaviour of the hermit crab Pagurus bernhardus

    Rimmer, J. E. V., Todd, C. D. & Shuker, D. M., 1 May 2021, In: Behavioural Processes. 104414.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  2. The rationality of decisions depends on behavioural context

    Glaser, G. L., Miller, M. C., Healy, S. D. & Shuker, D. M., 5 Dec 2020, In: Behavioural Processes. In-press, 104293.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  3. Same-sex sexual behaviour

    Balfour, V. L. & Shuker, D. M., 16 Nov 2020, In: Current Biology. 30, 22, p. R1345-R1346

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  4. A single pleiotropic locus influences the rate of hybridization between two sibling species of Lygaeus bugs

    Balfour, V., Black, D. & Shuker, D. M., Nov 2020, In: Ecology and Evolution. 10, 21, p. 12224-12232 9 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  5. Genomics of sex allocation in the parasitoid wasp Nasonia vitripennis

    Pannebakker, B. A., Cook, N., van den Heuvel, J., van de Zande, L. & Shuker, D. M., 20 Jul 2020, In: BMC Genomics. 21, 14 p., 499.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Related by journal

  1. Behavioral Ecology (Journal)

    Will Cresswell (Reviewer)

    26 Apr 2018

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  2. Behavioral Ecology (Journal)

    Susan Denise Healy (Editor)

    20122014

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  3. Behavioral Ecology (Journal)

    Iain McCombe Matthews (Reviewer)

    2007 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  4. Behavioral Ecology (Journal)

    Susan Denise Healy (Editor)

    20072014

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  5. Behavioral Ecology (Journal)

    Will Cresswell (Editor)

    20062010

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

Related by journal

  1. Does the response of D. melanogaster males to intrasexual competitors influence sexual isolation?

    Marie-Orleach, L., Sanz, A. M., Bailey, N. W. & Ritchie, M. G., Mar 2020, In: Behavioral Ecology. 31, 2, p. 487-492 6 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  2. It’s not all about temperature: breeding success also affects nest design

    Edwards, S. C., Shoot, T. T., Martin, R. J., Sherry, D. F. & Healy, S. D., 1 Jul 2020, In: Behavioral Ecology. 31, 4, p. 1065-1072 araa052.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  3. Juvenile socio-ecological environment shapes material technology in nest-building birds

    Breen, A. J., Lovie, K. E., Guerard, C., Edwards, S. C., Cooper, J., Healy, S. D. & Guillette, L. M., 30 Apr 2020, In: Behavioral Ecology. Advance Articles, araa027.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  4. Local mate competition modifies the costs of mating in a mostly monandrous parasitoid wasp

    Boulton, R. A., Cook, N., Greenway, E. V., Glaser, G. L., Green, J. & Shuker, D. M., 5 Apr 2019, In: Behavioral Ecology. 30, 2, p. 417-425 9 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

  5. Necessity creates opportunities for chimpanzee tool use

    Grund, C., Neumann, C., Zuberbuehler, K. & Gruber, T., Jul 2019, In: Behavioral Ecology. 30, 4, p. 1136-1144 9 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

ID: 184426877

Top