Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

The evolution of self-control

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Standard

The evolution of self-control. / MacLean, Evan L; Hare, Brian; Nunn, Charles L; Addessi, Elsa; Amici, Federica; Anderson, Rindy C; Aureli, Filippo; Baker, Joseph M; Bania, Amanda E; Barnard, Allison M; Boogert, Neeltje J; Brannon, Elizabeth M; Bray, Emily E; Bray, Joel; Brent, Lauren J N; Burkart, Judith M; Call, Josep; Cantlon, Jessica F; Cheke, Lucy G; Clayton, Nicola S; Delgado, Mikel M; DiVincenti, Louis J; Fujita, Kazuo; Herrmann, Esther; Hiramatsu, Chihiro; Jacobs, Lucia F; Jordan, Kerry E; Laude, Jennifer R; Leimgruber, Kristin L; Messer, Emily J E; Moura, Antonio C de A; Ostojić, Ljerka; Picard, Alejandra; Platt, Michael L; Plotnik, Joshua M; Range, Friederike; Reader, Simon M; Reddy, Rachna B; Sandel, Aaron A; Santos, Laurie R; Schumann, Katrin; Seed, Amanda M; Sewall, Kendra B; Shaw, Rachael C; Slocombe, Katie E; Su, Yanjie; Takimoto, Ayaka; Tan, Jingzhi; Tao, Ruoting; van Schaik, Carel P; Virányi, Zsófia; Visalberghi, Elisabetta; Wade, Jordan C; Watanabe, Arii; Widness, Jane; Young, Julie K; Zentall, Thomas R; Zhao, Yini.

In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, Vol. 111, No. 20, 20.05.2014, p. E2140- E2148.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Harvard

MacLean, EL, Hare, B, Nunn, CL, Addessi, E, Amici, F, Anderson, RC, Aureli, F, Baker, JM, Bania, AE, Barnard, AM, Boogert, NJ, Brannon, EM, Bray, EE, Bray, J, Brent, LJN, Burkart, JM, Call, J, Cantlon, JF, Cheke, LG, Clayton, NS, Delgado, MM, DiVincenti, LJ, Fujita, K, Herrmann, E, Hiramatsu, C, Jacobs, LF, Jordan, KE, Laude, JR, Leimgruber, KL, Messer, EJE, Moura, ACDA, Ostojić, L, Picard, A, Platt, ML, Plotnik, JM, Range, F, Reader, SM, Reddy, RB, Sandel, AA, Santos, LR, Schumann, K, Seed, AM, Sewall, KB, Shaw, RC, Slocombe, KE, Su, Y, Takimoto, A, Tan, J, Tao, R, van Schaik, CP, Virányi, Z, Visalberghi, E, Wade, JC, Watanabe, A, Widness, J, Young, JK, Zentall, TR & Zhao, Y 2014, 'The evolution of self-control', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 111, no. 20, pp. E2140- E2148. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1323533111

APA

MacLean, E. L., Hare, B., Nunn, C. L., Addessi, E., Amici, F., Anderson, R. C., ... Zhao, Y. (2014). The evolution of self-control. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 111(20), E2140- E2148. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1323533111

Vancouver

MacLean EL, Hare B, Nunn CL, Addessi E, Amici F, Anderson RC et al. The evolution of self-control. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2014 May 20;111(20):E2140- E2148. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1323533111

Author

MacLean, Evan L ; Hare, Brian ; Nunn, Charles L ; Addessi, Elsa ; Amici, Federica ; Anderson, Rindy C ; Aureli, Filippo ; Baker, Joseph M ; Bania, Amanda E ; Barnard, Allison M ; Boogert, Neeltje J ; Brannon, Elizabeth M ; Bray, Emily E ; Bray, Joel ; Brent, Lauren J N ; Burkart, Judith M ; Call, Josep ; Cantlon, Jessica F ; Cheke, Lucy G ; Clayton, Nicola S ; Delgado, Mikel M ; DiVincenti, Louis J ; Fujita, Kazuo ; Herrmann, Esther ; Hiramatsu, Chihiro ; Jacobs, Lucia F ; Jordan, Kerry E ; Laude, Jennifer R ; Leimgruber, Kristin L ; Messer, Emily J E ; Moura, Antonio C de A ; Ostojić, Ljerka ; Picard, Alejandra ; Platt, Michael L ; Plotnik, Joshua M ; Range, Friederike ; Reader, Simon M ; Reddy, Rachna B ; Sandel, Aaron A ; Santos, Laurie R ; Schumann, Katrin ; Seed, Amanda M ; Sewall, Kendra B ; Shaw, Rachael C ; Slocombe, Katie E ; Su, Yanjie ; Takimoto, Ayaka ; Tan, Jingzhi ; Tao, Ruoting ; van Schaik, Carel P ; Virányi, Zsófia ; Visalberghi, Elisabetta ; Wade, Jordan C ; Watanabe, Arii ; Widness, Jane ; Young, Julie K ; Zentall, Thomas R ; Zhao, Yini. / The evolution of self-control. In: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. 2014 ; Vol. 111, No. 20. pp. E2140- E2148.

Bibtex - Download

@article{d20067cd8098452a9c3bfa85995af09c,
title = "The evolution of self-control",
abstract = "Cognition presents evolutionary research with one of its greatest challenges. Cognitive evolution has been explained at the proximate level by shifts in absolute and relative brain volume and at the ultimate level by differences in social and dietary complexity. However, no study has integrated the experimental and phylogenetic approach at the scale required to rigorously test these explanations. Instead, previous research has largely relied on various measures of brain size as proxies for cognitive abilities. We experimentally evaluated these major evolutionary explanations by quantitatively comparing the cognitive performance of 567 individuals representing 36 species on two problem-solving tasks measuring self-control. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that absolute brain volume best predicted performance across species and accounted for considerably more variance than brain volume controlling for body mass. This result corroborates recent advances in evolutionary neurobiology and illustrates the cognitive consequences of cortical reorganization through increases in brain volume. Within primates, dietary breadth but not social group size was a strong predictor of species differences in self-control. Our results implicate robust evolutionary relationships between dietary breadth, absolute brain volume, and self-control. These findings provide a significant first step toward quantifying the primate cognitive phenome and explaining the process of cognitive evolution.",
keywords = "Psychology, Behavior, Comparative methods, Inhibitory control, Executive function",
author = "MacLean, {Evan L} and Brian Hare and Nunn, {Charles L} and Elsa Addessi and Federica Amici and Anderson, {Rindy C} and Filippo Aureli and Baker, {Joseph M} and Bania, {Amanda E} and Barnard, {Allison M} and Boogert, {Neeltje J} and Brannon, {Elizabeth M} and Bray, {Emily E} and Joel Bray and Brent, {Lauren J N} and Burkart, {Judith M} and Josep Call and Cantlon, {Jessica F} and Cheke, {Lucy G} and Clayton, {Nicola S} and Delgado, {Mikel M} and DiVincenti, {Louis J} and Kazuo Fujita and Esther Herrmann and Chihiro Hiramatsu and Jacobs, {Lucia F} and Jordan, {Kerry E} and Laude, {Jennifer R} and Leimgruber, {Kristin L} and Messer, {Emily J E} and Moura, {Antonio C de A} and Ljerka Ostojić and Alejandra Picard and Platt, {Michael L} and Plotnik, {Joshua M} and Friederike Range and Reader, {Simon M} and Reddy, {Rachna B} and Sandel, {Aaron A} and Santos, {Laurie R} and Katrin Schumann and Seed, {Amanda M} and Sewall, {Kendra B} and Shaw, {Rachael C} and Slocombe, {Katie E} and Yanjie Su and Ayaka Takimoto and Jingzhi Tan and Ruoting Tao and {van Schaik}, {Carel P} and Zs{\'o}fia Vir{\'a}nyi and Elisabetta Visalberghi and Wade, {Jordan C} and Arii Watanabe and Jane Widness and Young, {Julie K} and Zentall, {Thomas R} and Yini Zhao",
note = "This work was supported by the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center (NESCent) through support of a working group led by C.L.N. and B.H. NESCent is supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) EF-0905606. For training in phylogenetic comparative methods, we thank the AnthroTree Workshop (supported by NSF BCS-0923791). Y.S. thanks the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Project 31170995) and National Basic Research Program (973 Program: 2010CB833904). E.E.B. thanks the Duke Vertical Integration Program and the Duke Undergraduate Research Support Office. J.M.P. was supported by a Newton International Fellowship from the Royal Society and the British Academy. L.R.S. thanks the James S. McDonnell Foundation for Award 220020242. L.J.N.B. and M.L.P. acknowledge the National Institutes of Mental Health (R01-MH096875 and R01-MH089484), a Duke Institute for Brain Sciences Incubator Award (to M.L.P.), and a Duke Center for Interdisciplinary Decision Sciences Fellowship (to L.J.N.B.). E.V. and E.A. thank the Programma Nazionale per la Ricerca–Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR) Aging Program 2012–2014 for financial support, Roma Capitale–Museo Civico di Zoologia and Fondazione Bioparco for hosting the Istituto di Scienze e Tecnologie della Cognizione–CNR Unit of Cognitive Primatology and Primate Centre, and Massimiliano Bianchi and Simone Catarinacci for assistance with capuchin monkeys. K.F. thanks the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) for Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research 20220004. F. Aureli thanks the Stages in the Evolution and Development of Sign Use project (Contract 012-984 NESTPathfinder) and the Integrating Cooperation Research Across Europe project (Contract 043318), both funded by the European Community’s Sixth Framework Programme (FP6/2002–2006). F. Amici was supported by Humboldt Research Fellowship for Postdoctoral Researchers (Humboldt ID 1138999). L.F.J. and M.M.D. acknowledge NSF Electrical, Communications, and Cyber Systems Grant 1028319 (to L.F.J.) and an NSF Graduate Fellowship (to M.M.D.). C.H. thanks Grant-in-Aid for JSPS Fellows (10J04395). A.T. thanks Research Fellowships of the JSPS for Young Scientists (21264). F.R. and Z.V. acknowledge Austrian Science Fund (FWF) Project P21244-B17, the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007–2013)/ERC Grant Agreement 311870 (to F.R.), Vienna Science and Technology Fund Project CS11-026 (to Z.V.), and many private sponsors, including Royal Canin for financial support and the Game Park Ernstbrunn for hosting the Wolf Science Center. S.M.R. thanks the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (Canada). J.K.Y. thanks the US Department of Agriculture–Wildlife Services–National Wildlife Research Center. J.F.C. thanks the James S. McDonnell Foundation and Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. E.L.M. and B.H. thank the Duke Lemur Center and acknowledge National Institutes of Health Grant 5 R03 HD070649-02 and NSF Grants DGE-1106401, NSF-BCS-27552, and NSF-BCS-25172. This is Publication 1265 of the Duke Lemur Center.",
year = "2014",
month = "5",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1073/pnas.1323533111",
language = "English",
volume = "111",
pages = "E2140-- E2148",
journal = "Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America",
issn = "0027-8424",
publisher = "NATL ACAD SCIENCES",
number = "20",

}

RIS (suitable for import to EndNote) - Download

TY - JOUR

T1 - The evolution of self-control

AU - MacLean, Evan L

AU - Hare, Brian

AU - Nunn, Charles L

AU - Addessi, Elsa

AU - Amici, Federica

AU - Anderson, Rindy C

AU - Aureli, Filippo

AU - Baker, Joseph M

AU - Bania, Amanda E

AU - Barnard, Allison M

AU - Boogert, Neeltje J

AU - Brannon, Elizabeth M

AU - Bray, Emily E

AU - Bray, Joel

AU - Brent, Lauren J N

AU - Burkart, Judith M

AU - Call, Josep

AU - Cantlon, Jessica F

AU - Cheke, Lucy G

AU - Clayton, Nicola S

AU - Delgado, Mikel M

AU - DiVincenti, Louis J

AU - Fujita, Kazuo

AU - Herrmann, Esther

AU - Hiramatsu, Chihiro

AU - Jacobs, Lucia F

AU - Jordan, Kerry E

AU - Laude, Jennifer R

AU - Leimgruber, Kristin L

AU - Messer, Emily J E

AU - Moura, Antonio C de A

AU - Ostojić, Ljerka

AU - Picard, Alejandra

AU - Platt, Michael L

AU - Plotnik, Joshua M

AU - Range, Friederike

AU - Reader, Simon M

AU - Reddy, Rachna B

AU - Sandel, Aaron A

AU - Santos, Laurie R

AU - Schumann, Katrin

AU - Seed, Amanda M

AU - Sewall, Kendra B

AU - Shaw, Rachael C

AU - Slocombe, Katie E

AU - Su, Yanjie

AU - Takimoto, Ayaka

AU - Tan, Jingzhi

AU - Tao, Ruoting

AU - van Schaik, Carel P

AU - Virányi, Zsófia

AU - Visalberghi, Elisabetta

AU - Wade, Jordan C

AU - Watanabe, Arii

AU - Widness, Jane

AU - Young, Julie K

AU - Zentall, Thomas R

AU - Zhao, Yini

N1 - This work was supported by the National Evolutionary Synthesis Center (NESCent) through support of a working group led by C.L.N. and B.H. NESCent is supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) EF-0905606. For training in phylogenetic comparative methods, we thank the AnthroTree Workshop (supported by NSF BCS-0923791). Y.S. thanks the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Project 31170995) and National Basic Research Program (973 Program: 2010CB833904). E.E.B. thanks the Duke Vertical Integration Program and the Duke Undergraduate Research Support Office. J.M.P. was supported by a Newton International Fellowship from the Royal Society and the British Academy. L.R.S. thanks the James S. McDonnell Foundation for Award 220020242. L.J.N.B. and M.L.P. acknowledge the National Institutes of Mental Health (R01-MH096875 and R01-MH089484), a Duke Institute for Brain Sciences Incubator Award (to M.L.P.), and a Duke Center for Interdisciplinary Decision Sciences Fellowship (to L.J.N.B.). E.V. and E.A. thank the Programma Nazionale per la Ricerca–Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR) Aging Program 2012–2014 for financial support, Roma Capitale–Museo Civico di Zoologia and Fondazione Bioparco for hosting the Istituto di Scienze e Tecnologie della Cognizione–CNR Unit of Cognitive Primatology and Primate Centre, and Massimiliano Bianchi and Simone Catarinacci for assistance with capuchin monkeys. K.F. thanks the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS) for Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research 20220004. F. Aureli thanks the Stages in the Evolution and Development of Sign Use project (Contract 012-984 NESTPathfinder) and the Integrating Cooperation Research Across Europe project (Contract 043318), both funded by the European Community’s Sixth Framework Programme (FP6/2002–2006). F. Amici was supported by Humboldt Research Fellowship for Postdoctoral Researchers (Humboldt ID 1138999). L.F.J. and M.M.D. acknowledge NSF Electrical, Communications, and Cyber Systems Grant 1028319 (to L.F.J.) and an NSF Graduate Fellowship (to M.M.D.). C.H. thanks Grant-in-Aid for JSPS Fellows (10J04395). A.T. thanks Research Fellowships of the JSPS for Young Scientists (21264). F.R. and Z.V. acknowledge Austrian Science Fund (FWF) Project P21244-B17, the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Seventh Framework Programme (FP/2007–2013)/ERC Grant Agreement 311870 (to F.R.), Vienna Science and Technology Fund Project CS11-026 (to Z.V.), and many private sponsors, including Royal Canin for financial support and the Game Park Ernstbrunn for hosting the Wolf Science Center. S.M.R. thanks the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (Canada). J.K.Y. thanks the US Department of Agriculture–Wildlife Services–National Wildlife Research Center. J.F.C. thanks the James S. McDonnell Foundation and Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. E.L.M. and B.H. thank the Duke Lemur Center and acknowledge National Institutes of Health Grant 5 R03 HD070649-02 and NSF Grants DGE-1106401, NSF-BCS-27552, and NSF-BCS-25172. This is Publication 1265 of the Duke Lemur Center.

PY - 2014/5/20

Y1 - 2014/5/20

N2 - Cognition presents evolutionary research with one of its greatest challenges. Cognitive evolution has been explained at the proximate level by shifts in absolute and relative brain volume and at the ultimate level by differences in social and dietary complexity. However, no study has integrated the experimental and phylogenetic approach at the scale required to rigorously test these explanations. Instead, previous research has largely relied on various measures of brain size as proxies for cognitive abilities. We experimentally evaluated these major evolutionary explanations by quantitatively comparing the cognitive performance of 567 individuals representing 36 species on two problem-solving tasks measuring self-control. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that absolute brain volume best predicted performance across species and accounted for considerably more variance than brain volume controlling for body mass. This result corroborates recent advances in evolutionary neurobiology and illustrates the cognitive consequences of cortical reorganization through increases in brain volume. Within primates, dietary breadth but not social group size was a strong predictor of species differences in self-control. Our results implicate robust evolutionary relationships between dietary breadth, absolute brain volume, and self-control. These findings provide a significant first step toward quantifying the primate cognitive phenome and explaining the process of cognitive evolution.

AB - Cognition presents evolutionary research with one of its greatest challenges. Cognitive evolution has been explained at the proximate level by shifts in absolute and relative brain volume and at the ultimate level by differences in social and dietary complexity. However, no study has integrated the experimental and phylogenetic approach at the scale required to rigorously test these explanations. Instead, previous research has largely relied on various measures of brain size as proxies for cognitive abilities. We experimentally evaluated these major evolutionary explanations by quantitatively comparing the cognitive performance of 567 individuals representing 36 species on two problem-solving tasks measuring self-control. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that absolute brain volume best predicted performance across species and accounted for considerably more variance than brain volume controlling for body mass. This result corroborates recent advances in evolutionary neurobiology and illustrates the cognitive consequences of cortical reorganization through increases in brain volume. Within primates, dietary breadth but not social group size was a strong predictor of species differences in self-control. Our results implicate robust evolutionary relationships between dietary breadth, absolute brain volume, and self-control. These findings provide a significant first step toward quantifying the primate cognitive phenome and explaining the process of cognitive evolution.

KW - Psychology

KW - Behavior

KW - Comparative methods

KW - Inhibitory control

KW - Executive function

U2 - 10.1073/pnas.1323533111

DO - 10.1073/pnas.1323533111

M3 - Article

VL - 111

SP - E2140- E2148

JO - Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

JF - Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

SN - 0027-8424

IS - 20

ER -

Related by author

  1. Comparing humans and nonhuman great apes in the broken cloth problem: is their knowledge causal or perceptual?

    Albiach-Serrano, A., Sebastián-Enesco, C., Seed, A., Colmenares, F. & Call, J., Nov 2015, In : Journal of Experimental Child Psychology. 139, p. 174-189 16 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Abstract knowledge in the broken-string problem: evidence from nonhuman primates and pre-schoolers

    Mayer, C. P., Call, J., Albiach-Serrano, A., Visalberghi, E., Sabbatini, G. & Seed, A. M., 1 Oct 2014, In : PLoS One. 9, 10, 7 p., e108597.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Space or physics? Children use physical reasoning to solve the trap problem from 2.5 years of age

    Seed, A. M. & Call, J., Jul 2014, In : Developmental Psychology. 50, 7, p. 1951-1962 12 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Related by journal

  1. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (Journal)

    Michael Martin Nevels (Guest editor)
    Jul 2016 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesEditor of research journal

  2. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (Journal)

    Oscar Eduardo Gaggiotti (Member of editorial board)
    1 Jan 2013 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  3. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (Journal)

    Terry K Smith (Member of editorial board)
    2012 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  4. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (Journal)

    Terry K Smith (Member of editorial board)
    2008 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

  5. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (Journal)

    Gareth Brian Miles (Reviewer)
    2006 → …

    Activity: Publication peer-review and editorial work typesPeer review of manuscripts

Related by journal

  1. Acute social isolation alters neurogenomic state in songbird forebrain

    George, J., Bell, Z., Condliffe, D., Doher, K., Abaurrea, T., Spencer, K., Leitao, A., Gahr, M., Hurd, P. & Clayton, D. F., 22 Jul 2019, In : Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Latest Articles

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Asymmetric base pair opening drives helicase unwinding dynamics

    Colizzi, F., Perez-Gonzalez, C., Fritzen, R., Levy, Y., White, M. F., Penedo-Esteiro, J. C. & Bussi, G., 18 Oct 2019, In : Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Early, 7 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Asymmetries between achromatic and chromatic extraction of 3D motion signals

    Kaestner, M., Maloney, R., Wailes-Newson, K., Bloj, M., Harris, J., Morland, A. & Wade, A., 17 Jun 2019, In : Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Latest Articles, 10 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  4. Great apes use self-experience to anticipate an agent’s action in a false belief test

    Kano, F., Krupenye, C., Hirata, S., Tomonaga, M. & Call, J., 30 Sep 2019, In : Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Latest Articles

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

ID: 136104392

Top