Skip to content

Research at St Andrews

The liberal treatment of difference: an untimely meditation on culture and civilization

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle


Open Access permissions



School/Research organisations


John Stuart Mill’s liberal vision included a notion of “civil advancement” whereby the free expression of a diversity of opinion would result not only in an initial collision of difference but also in an eventual consolidation as truth. The work of this article is to explore the ways and extents in which such liberalism can translate into a cosmopolitan anthropology. Is toleration of difference the appropriate anthropological ethic, or can one hypothesize a liberal “magnanimous” overcoming of difference? In a wide-ranging discussion, the voice of Mill is juxtaposed against those of C. P. Snow, Ernest Gellner, Stevie Smith, and Karl Popper. Much commentary would suggest that liberalism is passé. A political context dominated by renascent particularisms, militant religions, and resurgent ethnicities spells the collapse, it is told, of any Enlightenment project of liberal-humanist universalism. “Cultures are not options.” Notwithstanding, the argument is made here that as “opinion” grades into “knowledge,” so “culture” grades into “civilization” and local community (polis) into global society (cosmos). Difference may become a step along the way to a recognition of universal human truth.


Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)687-710
Number of pages24
JournalCurrent Anthropology
Issue number5
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2011

Discover related content
Find related publications, people, projects and more using interactive charts.

View graph of relations

Related by author

  1. The nature of a cosmopolitan anthropology and the nature of human difference

    Rapport, N., 29 Dec 2019, In : Anuac. 8, 2, p. 225-232

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. A cosmopolitan orientation to the future as human birthright

    Rapport, N., 8 Mar 2019, American Ethnologist: Conversations.

    Research output: Contribution to specialist publicationArticle

  3. An anthropology of the Enlightenment: moral social relations then and today

    Rapport, N. (ed.) & Wardle, H. (ed.), 27 Dec 2018, London: Bloomsbury. 190 p. (Association of social anthropologists monographs)

    Research output: Book/ReportBook

Related by journal

  1. Learning to see climate change: children’s perceptions of environmental transformation in Mongolia, Mexico, Arctic Alaska, and the United Kingdom

    Irvine, R. D. G., Bodenhorn, B., Lee, E. & Amarbayasgalan, D., 27 Dec 2019, In : Current Anthropology. 60, 6, p. 723-740

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  2. Writing with twisted cords: the inscriptive capacity of Andean khipus

    Hyland, S. P., Jun 2017, In : Current Anthropology. 58, 3, p. 412-419

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  3. Comment on João de Pina Cabral's Brazilian Serialities: Personhood and Radical Embodied Cognition

    Harris, M., Jun 2016, In : Current Anthropology. 57, 3, p. 255-256 2 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

  4. Anthropology through Levinas: knowing the uniqueness of ego and the mystery of otherness

    Rapport, N. J., Apr 2015, In : Current Anthropology. 56, 2, p. 256-276 20 p.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

ID: 16905697